how many calories should you actually eat? a dietitian explains

how to calculate macros, best macro calculator, how many calories should i eat to gain muscle, healthy calorie deficit

how many calories should you actually eat? a dietitian explains

You can Google a macro calculator, enter your age, height, weight, and activity level, and have a set of numbers in about 30 seconds.

Easy enough, right?

But here’s what that calculator can’t tell you.

Whether you should be trying to lose weight in the first place.

Whether the 1,700 calories you’ve been eating are actually enough to support your workouts.

Whether your dieting history, health conditions, stress levels, or daily movement should change the recommendation.

And whether those numbers will help you build the stronger, leaner body you’re working toward.

I recently talked with a woman interested in Eat to Lean coaching who was exercising five days a week and eating around 1,700 calories. She was confident she wasn’t undereating because, hey, at least she wasn’t eating 1,200 calories.

I get it. We’ve made progress in helping women understand that 1,200 calories isn’t some universal weight-loss prescription.

But eating more than 1,200 doesn’t automatically mean you’re eating enough.

For one woman, 1,700 calories might be a reasonable deficit. For another, it could be far too little. For someone else, it might be close to maintenance.

The number alone tells me almost nothing.

So if you’ve been searching for the best macro calculator, I want to show you what actually goes into determining appropriate calorie and macro targets.

Because the math? That’s usually the easiest part.

why the best macro calculator can't tell you everything

Let’s start with what a calculator can do.

Most online macro calculators use established equations to estimate how much energy your body needs at rest. Then they apply an activity factor to estimate how many calories you might need throughout the day.

That’s a reasonable starting point.

But it’s still an estimate.

And the calculator is only working with the information you give it.

It doesn’t know that you’ve been dieting on and off for 15 years.

It doesn’t know that your strength workouts have been suffering.

It doesn’t know that you’re sleeping five hours a night, managing type 2 diabetes, or walking 12,000 steps every day because you’re on your feet at work.

It also doesn’t know whether the goal you selected is actually the goal that makes the most sense for your body.

You might select “lose weight” when what you really want is more muscle definition.

Those aren’t always the same thing.

So when someone asks me for the best macro calculator, my answer isn’t that we need a more complicated equation.

We need better information about the person using it.

Here’s how I approach that process.

decision #1: what are you actually trying to accomplish?

Let’s say you come to me and say, “Emily, I want to lose 15 pounds.”

My first question isn’t necessarily how quickly you want to lose them.

It’s what you’re hoping will be different when those 15 pounds are gone.

Do you want your clothes to fit differently?

Do you want to see more definition in your arms?

Do you want to feel stronger during your workouts?

Are you concerned about blood sugar or another health marker?

Or do you simply want to feel more comfortable in your body?

Those answers matter.

Because weight loss, fat loss, and improved body composition aren’t interchangeable goals.

when losing weight isn’t the most direct route to your goal

Imagine a woman who’s already at a relatively healthy body weight but wants more muscle definition.

She hasn’t been strength training consistently, and she’s spent much of the last year eating in a calorie deficit.

Would cutting another 300 calories automatically help her get the look she’s after?

Not necessarily.

She might benefit more from eating at maintenance, following a progressive strength training program, and giving her body enough energy to build muscle.

This is especially important if you’re wondering, how many calories should i eat to gain muscle?

The answer isn’t automatically “eat as much as possible.” But it also isn’t “keep dieting until you’re lean enough to start building muscle.”

Your current body composition, training experience, energy intake, and goals all influence the strategy.

And sometimes the most productive thing you can do is stop pursuing weight loss for a while.

On the other hand, if you have body fat you’d like to lose, you’re strength training consistently, and you have the capacity to follow a moderate deficit, a healthy calorie deficit might be entirely appropriate.

The goal is to match your nutrition strategy to the outcome you actually want.

Not to assume that every woman needs fewer calories.

decision #2: what is your current calorie intake actually doing?

Before I recommend new numbers, I want to understand your current ones.

Let’s say you tell me you’re eating 1,600 calories per day.

My first question might be: How do you know?

Are you tracking consistently?

Are you weighing and measuring portions?

Is 1,600 your actual average over seven days?

Or is it your Monday-through-Thursday target before the weekend looks completely different?

I’m not asking because I think you’re lying.

I’m asking because those details help me understand how reliable the number is.

Some women unintentionally underestimate their intake. Others are tracking accurately and genuinely eating what they report.

I don’t want to assume either situation without more information.

your weight trend tells us more than one weigh-in

Now let’s say you’ve been eating an average of 1,800 calories for several months.

If your average weight has remained relatively stable, that suggests your intake may be close to maintenance, assuming your tracking is reasonably accurate.

If you’re gradually losing weight, that’s different information.

And if you’re eating 1,800 calories while feeling constantly hungry, struggling through workouts, and recovering poorly, I want to know that, too.

This is why how to calculate macros isn’t just about plugging numbers into an equation.

It’s about understanding what your body is already doing.

I also want to know what happens over time.

A two-pound increase after a restaurant dinner doesn’t tell me your calories are too high.

But a gradual increase in your average weight over six to eight weeks is a trend worth investigating.

The same goes for fat loss.

If you’re pursuing a healthy calorie deficit, I want to see whether your weight trend, energy, strength, and consistency suggest the plan is working.

Not whether you managed to hit an exact calorie number yesterday.

your old diet calories aren’t necessarily your maintenance calories

I see women who’ve been eating somewhere between 1,500 and 1,800 calories for years.

Sometimes that’s appropriate.

Sometimes it’s not.

But the fact that you’ve gotten used to eating a certain amount doesn’t mean it’s the amount your body needs.

And the calorie target that helped you lose weight five years ago isn’t automatically your maintenance target today.

Your activity, body composition, and circumstances may have changed.

So before you search for the best macro calculator and choose another number, take a look at the information you already have.

What are you eating?

What’s happening with your weight?

How do you feel?

How are your workouts going?

Those answers matter.

decision #3: what does your health and dieting history tell me?

This might be the most important part of the entire process.

Two women can be the same age, height, and weight, exercise the same number of days per week, and still need very different nutrition strategies.

Why?

Because their health histories and life circumstances are different.

years of dieting can change what we prioritize

Maybe you’ve spent the last 15 years moving from Weight Watchers to keto to intermittent fasting to macro tracking.

You know how to follow a diet.

But you’ve rarely spent time intentionally eating at maintenance.

If your only two modes are “actively trying to lose weight” and “not paying attention to nutrition,” you may benefit from learning what consistent maintenance eating looks like.

That doesn’t mean your metabolism is permanently damaged.

And it doesn’t mean you need some special metabolic repair process.

But repeated dieting can affect hunger, activity, body composition, and the habits you’ve developed around food.

For someone with that history, I might recommend spending time at maintenance before pursuing another healthy calorie deficit.

That could give you room to improve training performance, establish consistent meals, eat enough protein, and practice maintaining your weight.

Sometimes that’s a much more productive next step than cutting calories again.

glucose-related conditions deserve more than a carb target

I also want to know whether you’re managing type 2 diabetes, prediabetes, PCOS, insulin resistance, or another condition that affects your nutrition needs.

Having insulin resistance doesn’t automatically mean carbohydrates are the enemy.

And it doesn’t mean energy balance stops mattering.

But it may change how we structure your meals.

For someone managing diabetes, I might pay closer attention to carbohydrate distribution throughout the day, fiber intake, and how carbohydrates are paired with protein and fat.

If medications that lower blood glucose are involved, changes to food intake may need to be coordinated with a medical provider.

The goal isn’t simply to hit a carbohydrate number.

It’s to create an approach that supports health and is realistic enough to follow.

stress and recovery matter, especially in midlife

Picture a woman who’s working full-time, caring for kids or aging parents, sleeping five or six hours a night, and squeezing in five intense workouts every week.

She’s exhausted.

Her workouts aren’t going well.

And she wants to lose another 15 pounds.

Could I calculate a deficit for her?

Absolutely.

But should that be my first recommendation?

Not necessarily.

High stress doesn’t magically override energy balance. Cortisol isn’t making fat loss impossible regardless of what you eat.

But stress can affect appetite, sleep, recovery, food choices, and daily movement.

If you’re already running on fumes, adding another restrictive demand might make everything harder.

Sometimes maintaining your weight while improving sleep, recovery, and meal consistency is the smarter short-term strategy.

digestive symptoms can change the plan, too

Maybe you’re trying to eat more protein but dealing with persistent bloating or constipation.

Or you’ve been avoiding certain foods because they make you uncomfortable.

I want to know that before recommending a dramatic increase in fiber or a meal plan built around foods you can’t tolerate.

We might need to adjust food choices, increase fiber gradually, distribute protein differently, or involve a medical provider if symptoms need evaluation.

And of course, pregnancy, breastfeeding, medications, and other health conditions can also change what an appropriate nutrition plan looks like.

This is why knowing how to calculate macros is only one part of personalized nutrition.

The bigger question is whether the resulting targets make sense for your health.

decision #4: what does your daily life actually demand?

Here’s a question I wish more macro calculators asked:

What does your day actually look like outside the gym?

Because “I work out four days a week” doesn’t tell me everything I need to know.

Imagine two women who are both 45 years old, weigh 155 pounds, and strength train three days a week.

One works at a desk and averages 3,000 steps a day.

The other works on her feet, walks her dog every morning, and averages 12,000 steps.

Same age.

Same weight.

Same gym schedule.

Very different daily energy demands.

your workouts aren’t your only source of activity

We tend to focus on the calories burned during structured exercise.

But walking around the house, taking the stairs, running errands, doing chores, and moving throughout the workday all contribute to energy expenditure.

The type of training matters, too.

Four strength workouts are different from four marathon training sessions.

And four challenging strength workouts are different from four sessions of gentle movement.

Frequency, intensity, duration, and recovery all provide useful information.

This is also why copying your friend’s macros rarely makes sense.

Maybe she’s losing weight while eating 1,900 calories.

That doesn’t mean 1,900 is automatically the right target for you.

You’re not living in her body or following her routine.

And if you’re asking how many calories should i eat to gain muscle, your training demands become especially important.

Building muscle requires a reason for your body to adapt, which is where progressive strength training comes in, along with adequate nutrition and recovery.

The calorie target needs to support the work you’re asking your body to do.

life stage is part of the picture

Pregnancy and breastfeeding bring nutritional needs that require specific consideration.

And for women in perimenopause or postmenopause, I want to understand what’s happening with training, sleep, recovery, muscle mass, and body composition.

Menopause doesn’t mean your metabolism suddenly stops working.

But changes in hormones, body composition, sleep, and activity can influence the bigger picture.

That’s why I don’t want to use the same generic activity setting for every woman and call it personalized.

decision #5: what starting targets make sense, and how will we know they’re working?

Now we finally get to the math.

By this point, I’ve learned about your goals, current intake, health history, training, and daily activity.

That gives me a much better foundation for estimating your energy needs.

There are established equations we can use to estimate resting energy expenditure, then account for activity and other factors to estimate total daily needs.

But even with a thorough assessment, these numbers are estimates.

I’m not measuring your exact metabolism through a questionnaire.

I’m making an informed recommendation using the information available.

choosing maintenance, a deficit, or another approach

First, I decide what kind of calorie target makes sense.

For some women, that’s maintenance.

For others, it’s a healthy calorie deficit that supports fat loss without unnecessarily compromising training, recovery, or consistency.

And for women prioritizing muscle growth, the calorie recommendation needs to support that goal.

If you’re wondering how many calories should i eat to gain muscle, there’s no universal number that applies to every woman.

Your maintenance needs, training, current intake, and body composition all matter.

The same is true for fat loss.

A larger deficit may produce faster weight loss initially, but that doesn’t automatically make it a better long-term strategy.

I generally prefer a moderate approach when fat loss is appropriate because I want you to have a reasonable opportunity to preserve muscle, train effectively, and actually follow the plan.

how to calculate macros after setting calories

Once we’ve determined an appropriate calorie target, we can work on the macronutrient distribution.

Protein is a priority for many of the women I work with because it supports muscle maintenance and growth, recovery, and satiety.

That’s especially relevant if you’re strength training or pursuing fat loss.

But protein targets still need to reflect your body size, goals, training, and relevant health considerations.

Then we allocate enough dietary fat and carbohydrates to support overall nutrition, health, and performance.

And here’s something I want you to remember:

There isn’t one magical ratio of protein, fat, and carbohydrates that every woman needs to follow.

Some women feel and perform great with more carbohydrates.

Others prefer a different distribution based on appetite, food preferences, or health considerations.

Both approaches can be reasonable.

So if you’ve been trying to learn how to calculate macros, don’t get so caught up in finding a perfect ratio that you forget to ask whether you can actually follow it.

I could calculate a beautiful macro prescription on paper.

But if it requires six elaborate meals a day, foods you hate, and a completely different lifestyle, how useful is it?

your starting macros aren’t your forever macros

Let’s say I recommend 1,850 calories.

That doesn’t mean 1,849 is perfect and 1,851 is failure.

Your body doesn’t recognize an exact calorie threshold like that.

It’s a starting estimate.

And then we evaluate.

Are your average weight and measurements changing in the direction we’d expect?

How are your workouts?

Are you recovering?

Are you constantly hungry?

Can you follow the plan consistently?

If you’re losing weight at an appropriate rate, maintaining strength, and feeling good, we may not need to change anything.

If progress isn’t happening as expected, we look at tracking accuracy, adherence, activity, and how long we’ve been evaluating before automatically lowering calories.

And if you’re exhausted, excessively hungry, or getting weaker in the gym, those are reasons to take a closer look at the plan.

Your macros aren’t a test you pass or fail every day.

They’re a tool.

And the tool should be evaluated based on whether it’s helping you reach your goals.

three women, one calculator, three different strategies

Let’s pull this together.

Imagine three women entering their information into the same online calculator and receiving roughly the same estimated maintenance calories.

Woman #1: She’s strength training consistently, sleeping well, maintaining her weight, and interested in losing a modest amount of body fat.

For her, a healthy calorie deficit might be a reasonable next step.

Woman #2: She’s spent 15 years cycling through diets, has never intentionally eaten at maintenance, and is struggling to recover from workouts.

For her, I might recommend maintenance calories, consistent meals, and better training support before considering fat loss.

Woman #3: She’s managing type 2 diabetes and persistent digestive symptoms.

For her, I want to understand medications, glucose management, food tolerances, and whether additional medical care is needed before deciding how to structure her nutrition.

Same calculator estimate.

Three different women.

Potentially three different nutrition strategies.

And that’s exactly why I don’t think the best macro calculator is necessarily the one that gives you the most precise-looking number.

It’s the one that helps you get started with a reasonable estimate, while recognizing that your actual needs require more context.

stop asking how little you can eat

If there’s one thing I want you to take away from this, it’s that your nutrition targets should support your life and goals.

Not just give you another number to chase.

Maybe you’ve been eating 1,600 calories for years because that’s what an old diet told you to do.

Maybe you’re lifting weights and wondering why you don’t feel stronger.

Maybe you’re asking how many calories should i eat to gain muscle because you’re tired of focusing exclusively on weight loss.

Or maybe you want to pursue fat loss, but you don’t know whether your current approach is a healthy calorie deficit or something unnecessarily restrictive.

Those are all good reasons to reassess.

Instead of asking, “What’s the lowest number of calories I can eat and still lose weight?”

Try asking:

“What’s an appropriate amount of food for my body, my goals, my health history, and the lifestyle I’m trying to build?”

That’s a much more useful question.

And answering it requires more than an equation.

ready to stop guessing at your macros?

If you’ve been searching for the best macro calculator, I want you to know there’s a more personalized way to approach your numbers.

My Custom Macro Calculation service takes your goals, current intake, activity, and relevant health history into account to help determine appropriate starting targets.

Custom Macro Calculations are also part of this year’s Black Friday promotion, so check the offer details before getting started.

And if you want to hear exactly how I work through these five decisions with clients, listen to Episode 84 of Macros Made Easy:

How Many Calories Should You Actually Eat? A Dietitian Explains

LISTEN TO EPISODE 84

Because learning how to calculate macros is useful.

But understanding whether those macros are right for you?

That’s where the real progress starts.

👉 Take the next step: If this message resonates, it is time to go beyond guessing. 

✅ Learn more about the Custom Macro Calculation
✅ Download the free DIY Macros Guide
✅ Take the Macro Mastery Quiz to find your best next step

[00:00:00] Emily Field: Welcome back to the Macros Made Easy podcast. This is episode 84, and today we’re talking about how to figure out how many calories and macros you should actually be eating. And I want to approach this conversation a little differently because I think we’ve gotten to a place where women have access to more nutrition information than ever before, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they have a better understanding of how much food their own bodies need.

 

[00:00:23] Emily Field: You can search for a macro calculator online, enter your height, weight, age, and activity level, and have a set of numbers in just about 30 seconds. But what that calculator can’t tell you is whether pursuing fat loss is even the right strategy for you, whether you’ve been chronically undereating, or whether your health history might change the nutrition recommendations I’d make.

 

[00:00:43] Emily Field: So today, I’m taking you behind the scenes of how I approach calculating macros for my clients. I’m sharing five decisions I make before recommending calorie and macro targets, and I think some of them might surprise you because the math is usually the easiest part. Figuring out what those numbers should mean for your body and your goals is where the real work happens.

 

[00:01:02] Emily Field: Before we get into today’s episode, I want to share a five-star Apple Podcasts review from a listener named Candace who titled her review, “My Favorite Podcast I Found on Macros. Very Educational.” Candace writes about finding the podcast at the beginning of her macro tracking journey and listening to every single episode.

 

[00:01:19] Emily Field: She says the information has helped her better understand nutrition, and she shares something I think is especially relevant to today’s conversation. “I’ve lost 36 pounds postpartum when following a macro style approach, eating more food than I ever have, and I feel I gained a lot more knowledge having her podcast to motivate and teach me along the way.”

 

[00:01:37] Emily Field: First of all, Candace, thank you so much for taking the time to leave this review. I love hearing that the podcast has been such a helpful resource for you. But what really stands out to me is that you were able to make progress towards your weight loss goals while eating more food than you had previously.

 

[00:01:52] Emily Field: I think so many women assume that if they want to lose weight, they need to keep finding ways to eat less and eat less and eat less. And while a calorie deficit is necessary for fat loss, that doesn’t mean that your calories need to be as low as possible. It’s also why I’m so passionate about helping women understand the why behind their nutrition recommendations.

 

[00:02:11] Emily Field: I don’t want you blindly following a calorie target because the app gave it to you or because it’s what worked for someone else. I want you to understand what your body needs, how your nutrition supports your goals, and how to make more informed decisions as those needs change. And that leads us perfectly into today’s episode because we’re gonna talk about what actually goes into determining your calorie and macro targets and why the number you’re currently eating might not be the right number for you.

 

[00:02:37] Emily Field: I recently had a conversation with a woman who was interested in Eat to Lean coaching, and something she said really stuck with me. She was exercising about five days a week, doing a combination of strength training and cardio, and she told me she was eating around seventeen hundred calories per day.

 

[00:02:50] Emily Field: She was pretty confident that she w- wasn’t undereating because in her mind, she wasn’t falling into that twelve hundred calorie trap. And listen, I appreciate that. I think we’ve made a lot of progress in helping women recognize that eating twelve hundred calories isn’t some universal requirement for losing weight.

 

[00:03:07] Emily Field: For many active women, that amount would be far too little food. But here’s the thing, just because you’re eating more than twelve hundred calories doesn’t automatically mean you’re eating enough. I didn’t know enough about this woman’s body composition, her activity outside the gym, her weight trends, her dieting history to determine whether seventeen hundred calories was appropriate for her, and that’s exactly the point.

 

[00:03:30] Emily Field: For one woman, seventeen hundred calories could represent a reasonable calorie deficit. For another, it could be an unnecessarily aggressive deficit that’s leaving her under-fueled. And for someone else, it could be closer to what she needs to maintain her current weight. The number by itself doesn’t tell me very much, and yet this is how so many women approach nutrition.

 

[00:03:50] Emily Field: They pick a calorie target from an app, an old diet, a friend, or an online calculator, and they spend months or even years trying to make their bodies respond to that number. When progress stalls, they assume they need to eat less. When they feel hungry, they assume they need more discipline, and when they can’t sustain the plan, they assume that they’re doing something wrong.

 

[00:04:11] Emily Field: But what if the problem isn’t your ability to follow numbers? What if we haven’t done enough work to determine whether those numbers were appropriate in the first place? That’s what I wanna help you understand today. When someone comes to me for a custom macro calculation, I’m not simply looking for a more sophisticated equation to plug their information into.

 

[00:04:30] Emily Field: I’m working through several decisions that help me determine what kind of nutrition strategy makes sense for that person. So let’s walk through those decisions. Decision number one is what are we actually trying to accomplish? The first decision I make is about the goal itself. Now, you might be thinking this is obvious.

 

[00:04:49] Emily Field: Someone comes to me and says, “Emily, I wanna lose 15 pounds,” so my job must be to calculate a calorie deficit that helps her lose 15 pounds. But that’s not necessarily where I start. I wanna understand what she’s hoping will be different when those 15 pounds are gone. Does she want her clothes to fit differently?

 

[00:05:06] Emily Field: Does she wanna see more muscle definition? Does she wanna feel stronger and more athletic? Is she concerned about her blood sugar or maybe another health marker? Does she simply wanna feel more comfortable in her body? Those answers matter because weight loss, fat loss, and improvements to body composition are not always the same thing.

 

[00:05:25] Emily Field: I might work with a woman who tells me she wants to lose weight, but when we talk a little more, she explains that she wants to see some definition in her arms, feel stronger in her workouts, and have more muscle tone. And that’s an important distinction because losing weight isn’t necessarily the most direct route to those results.

 

[00:05:42] Emily Field: If she’s already at a relatively healthy body weight, hasn’t been consistently strength training, or has been eating in a calorie deficit for a long time, I might recommend that she spend some time at maintenance while focusing on building muscle. That doesn’t mean I’m dismissing her desire to change her body.

 

[00:05:58] Emily Field: I’m trying to make sure that the strategy matches the outcome she’s actually looking for. On the other hand, if someone has a meaningful amount of body fat she’d like to lose, is already strength training consistently, has a relatively stable relationship with food, and has the capacity to follow a moderate deficit, then pursuing fat loss might make perfect sense.

 

[00:06:18] Emily Field: The point is, I don’t assume every woman who requests macros needs a weight loss prescription. Sometimes the most productive thing we can do is eat enough to support training, improve recovery, and build some consistency before we think about reducing calories. And I think that’s a difficult concept for a lot of women to accept, especially if they spent most of their adult lives believing that progress means seeing a smaller number on the scale.

 

[00:06:44] Emily Field: But if your ultimate goal is to be leaner, stronger, healthier, and more capable, we have to be willing to choose a nutrition strategy that supports those outcomes, even when that strategy doesn’t involve losing weight right away. Once I understand what we’re trying to accomplish, my next question is about where we’re starting Decision number two is what is your current calorie intake actually doing?

 

[00:07:09] Emily Field: This is one of my favorite conversations to have with clients because it often reveals how little we really know about the calorie numbers we’ve been following. I wanna know what you’re currently eating, how consistently you’re eating that amount, and what’s happening with your weight, hunger, energy, and performance.

 

[00:07:23] Emily Field: Let’s say you tell me you’re eating 1,600 calories a day. My first question might be, how do you know? Are you tracking your food? Are you weighing and measuring your portions? Is that an average from seven days of eating or is that what you aim for Monday through Thursday before eating looks completely different over the weekend?

 

[00:07:40] Emily Field: I’m not asking because I think you’re being dishonest. I’m asking because those details help me understand how much confidence we can place in that number. A lot of people unintentionally underestimate their intake. Others are tracking diligently and genuinely eating the amount they report. I don’t wanna assume either one without gathering more information.

 

[00:08:00] Emily Field: Then I wanna know what’s happening to your weight over time. If you’ve been consistently eating around 1,800 calories for several months and your average weight has remained relatively stable, that’s useful information. It suggests that your current average intake may be reasonably close to what your body is using, assuming your tracking is accurate and the trend is representative.

 

[00:08:21] Emily Field: But if you’ve been eating 1,800 calories and gradually losing weight, that’s a different situation. And if you’ve been eating 1,800 calories, feeling constantly hungry, struggling through your workouts, and noticing that your recovery has gotten worse, those details matter too. One thing I frequently ask women is, “How do you know what your maintenance calories are?”

 

[00:08:41] Emily Field: Because a calorie target that helped you lose weight five years ago isn’t necessarily your maintenance now. A number your fitness tracker gives you isn’t necessarily your maintenance. A calorie target you receive from an app after selecting lose two pounds per week certainly isn’t your maintenance.

 

[00:08:57] Emily Field: Yet women will spend years eating somewhere between 1,500 and 1,800 calories and assume they’re adequately fueling themselves simply because they’ve gotten used to that amount. I think a lot of women would be surprised by how much food they might be able to eat while maintaining their weight, particularly when they’re strength training and maintaining a good amount of daily movement.

 

[00:09:16] Emily Field: Of course, I can’t tell you what your maintenance calories are without learning more about you, and I don’t want to suggest that everyone’s number is secretly much higher than they think. What I do wanna challenge is the assumption that the number you’re familiar with is automatically the number that’s appropriate for you.

 

[00:09:33] Emily Field: This is why I like looking at patterns rather than isolated days. If someone’s weight went up two pounds after eating out on Saturday, that’s not particularly useful evidence that their calorie target is too high. But if their average weight has been gradually increasing over six to eight weeks, that’s a trend we should investigate The goal here isn’t to find one perfect number, it’s to understand what your body is currently doing so we can make a more informed decision about what to change.

 

[00:10:01] Emily Field: And that brings me to what might be the most important decision of this entire process. Decision number three: what does your health and dieting history tell me? If there’s one thing I wish more people understood about personalized nutrition, it’s that two people with nearly identical physical stats might need very different nutrition recommendations because their health histories are different.

 

[00:10:25] Emily Field: This is where I think online calculators fall especially short. A calculator might ask whether you’re 45 years old, weigh 155 pounds, and exercise three to four times per week. But it probably isn’t asking whether you’ve been dieting for 20 years or whether you have Type 2 diabetes or PCOS, what your stress level is like, or whether you’re dealing with digestive symptoms that affect what and how much you can comfortably eat.

 

[00:10:51] Emily Field: And those things can change the direction of a nutrition prescription. Let’s talk about a few examples. First, I wanna know about your dieting history. I work with a lot of women who have spent years cycling between periods of restriction and periods where they feel like they’ve been completely off track.

 

[00:11:08] Emily Field: Maybe they did Weight Watchers for a while, followed by keto, followed by intermittent fasting, followed by macro tracking. They know what it feels like to follow a diet, but they have very little experience intentionally eating at maintenance, and that matters. If your only two modes have been actively trying to lose weight or feeling like you’re no longer paying attention to your nutrition, you may not have developed the skills to maintain your weight comfortably.

 

[00:11:34] Emily Field: You might be great at following a set of rules for eight weeks, but struggle to figure out how to eat when those rules go away. For someone with that history, I might recommend spending time at maintenance before pursuing another calorie deficit. I’m not suggesting that your metabolism has been permanently damaged by dieting or that you have to go through some special metabolic repair process before fat loss becomes possible.

 

[00:11:57] Emily Field: I’m saying that repeated dieting can influence things like hunger, activity, body composition, and the behaviors you associate with eating. And after a long history of restriction, it can be helpful to establish a much more stable and sustainable way of eating before asking your body and your brain to tolerate another deficit.

 

[00:12:17] Emily Field: That maintenance phase might give you an opportunity to improve training performance, establish more consistent meals, practice eating enough protein, and learn what an appropriate amount of food actually looks like. For some women, that’s gonna be much more valuable than immediately subtracting another 300 calories from their day Next, I wanna know whether you’re managing any glucose-related conditions.

 

[00:12:41] Emily Field: This could be type 2 diabetes, pre-diabetes, PCOS or PMOS, or insulin resistance. Now, there’s a lot of misinformation out there suggesting that if you have insulin resistance, carbohydrates are automatically the enemy or that calories somehow stop mattering, and that’s not how I approach it. Energy balance still matters, but the way we structure your nutrition plan might look a little different.

 

[00:13:04] Emily Field: For example, if you’re managing type 2 diabetes, I might pay closer attention to how carbohydrates are distributed through your day, the quality and fiber content of those carbohydrates, how often you’re eating, and how you’re pairing carbohydrates with protein and fat. We might spend more time building consistent, balanced meals rather than simply giving you a carb target and telling you to hit it however you want.

 

[00:13:27] Emily Field: And if you’re using medication that lowers blood glucose, changing your food intake may require coordination with your medical provider, particularly if there’s a risk of hypoglycemia. With PCOS, or now the term PMOS, I might consider your health history of insulin resistance, current symptoms, medications, and the approach that’s going to help you manage your nutrition consistently over time.

 

[00:13:50] Emily Field: But the answer isn’t necessarily a very low-carb diet, and it certainly isn’t a guarantee that losing weight will solve every symptom. I want a nutrition plan that supports your health and is realistic enough to follow. Imagine two women who have the same calorie needs and the same goal of losing body fat.

 

[00:14:07] Emily Field: One is managing diabetes, and the other isn’t. We might arrive at a similar calorie target for both women, but I could approach their meal structure and carb distribution and other priorities very differently. That’s what I mean when I say health history matters I want to talk about stress and recovery because this is especially relevant for women in midlife.

 

[00:14:29] Emily Field: Let’s imagine a woman who’s working full-time, taking care of kids or aging parents, sleeping five or six hours a night, and squeezing in five intense workouts every week. She’s exhausted, she doesn’t feel like she’s recovering well, and she wants to lose another fifteen pounds. Could I calculate a calorie deficit for her?

 

[00:14:47] Emily Field: Yes, absolutely. But should that automatically be my first recommendation? No. I might have to consider whether adding another demand to an already overloaded lifestyle is gonna help her or make it even harder to sustain healthy habits. High stress doesn’t mean your body becomes exempt from energy balance.

 

[00:15:07] Emily Field: Cortisol isn’t magically preventing fat loss regardless of how much you eat. But stress can affect your appetite, sleep, recovery, food choices, and even how much you move throughout the day. If you’re running on fumes, you might find yourself relying on convenience foods because you have no energy to cook.

 

[00:15:25] Emily Field: You might feel hungrier or have a harder time regulating your appetite after a poor night’s sleep. You might also notice that your workouts are suffering or that you’re less active outside the gym because you’re exhausted. And sometimes we’re so focused on getting the calorie target lower that we ignore all the other things making that plan difficult to follow.

 

[00:15:45] Emily Field: For this woman, I might decide that maintaining her weight while improving sleep, meal consistency, and recovery is a better short-term strategy. That doesn’t mean she can never pursue fat loss. It means we’re choosing a time and an approach that’s more likely to support the results she wants. I want to emphasize that because I don’t think women need another reason to believe that their bodies are working against them.

 

[00:16:08] Emily Field: Your life circumstances matter, your recovery matters, and sometimes the most strategic decision is not to make your nutrition more restrictive Another area I pay attention to is digestive health. Let’s say someone comes to me wanting a high protein macro plan, but she’s also dealing with persistent bloating, constipation, or other GI symptoms.

 

[00:16:30] Emily Field: That information matters because the foods we choose to help her reach her macros also need to be foods she can tolerate. If she’s been avoiding entire categories of foods because they make her uncomfortable, I wanna understand what’s happening before I recommend that she dramatically increase her fiber or start eating large quantities of foods that might aggravate her symptoms.

 

[00:16:50] Emily Field: Maybe we need to increase fiber gradually. Maybe we need to find different protein sources or distribute food differently throughout the day. Maybe her digestive symptoms are significant enough that they need to be evaluated by a medical provider. And depending on what’s happening, we might need to address those issues before making fat loss the primary focus.

 

[00:17:10] Emily Field: There’s very little value in giving someone a plan that looks perfect on paper if following it makes her feel miserable. And of course, these aren’t the only things that matter in a health history. I wanna know about relevant medications, pregnancy or breastfeeding, medical conditions, menstrual or menopausal-related changes, and any other factors that might influence energy needs, food choices, or the appropriateness of a calorie deficit.

 

[00:17:36] Emily Field: And I’m not diagnosing these conditions through a macro calculation, and a nutrition prescription isn’t a replacement for medical treatment. But understanding someone’s health history helps me recognize when a nutrition strategy needs to be adjusted, when more information is needed, or when another healthcare professional should be involved.

 

[00:17:54] Emily Field: And here’s the point I really want you to take away from this decision. Sometimes health history changes how we distribute protein, fat, and carbohydrates, but sometimes it changes the entire direction of the plan. Instead of prescribing a calorie deficit, I might recommend maintenance. Instead of focusing on weight loss, we might prioritize meal consistency and adequate fueling.

 

[00:18:15] Emily Field: Instead of reducing carbs, we might work on how they’re distributed across the day and what foods they’re paired with. That’s why I don’t believe personalized nutrition can be reduced to finding the perfect equation. Now, we’ve talked about your goals, what your current intake is actually doing, and how your health history can shape the strategy.

 

[00:18:34] Emily Field: There are still two decisions I wanna walk you through, including how I take all of this information and turn it into an actual calorie and macro target. But before we get there, I wanna share something with you if you’re realizing that you’ve been guessing at your numbers for a long time Decision number four, what does your daily life actually demand?

 

[00:18:54] Emily Field: The fourth decision is about your energy needs, and this is where I wanna get more specific than just whether you exercise because, “I work out four days a week,” can mean very different things depending on the person. Maybe you lift weights for 45 minutes four times a week, but outside those workouts, you sit at a desk for eight or nine hours a day and average about 3,000 steps.

 

[00:19:14] Emily Field: Or maybe you lift weights four times a week, spend most of your workday on your feet, walk your dog every morning, and average 12,000 steps. Those two women could have the same height, weight, age, and gym schedule, but their total daily energy needs could be quite different. I think people underestimate the role of movement outside of structured exercise.

 

[00:19:33] Emily Field: We tend to give a lot of attention to how many calories we burn during a workout while overlooking the energy we use to walk around or do household chores, taking the stairs, running errands, and generally moving throughout our days. And when someone is trying to calculate her macros, that daily movement matters.

 

[00:19:51] Emily Field: I also wanna understand what kind of training she’s doing. Four strength workouts per week are different than four marathon training sessions, and four sessions of progressive strength training are very different from four workouts that are mostly low-intensity movement. The frequency, intensity, and duration all provide information about what someone’s body needs to support.

 

[00:20:12] Emily Field: And then we have to consider life stage. A pregnant or breastfeeding woman has nutritional needs that have to be accounted for differently from someone who isn’t pregnant or lactating. And a woman in perimenopause or postmenopause, I wanna understand what’s happening with their training, sleep, recovery, muscle mass, and body composition.

 

[00:20:31] Emily Field: Menopause doesn’t mean your metabolism suddenly stops working, but changes in hormones, body composition, sleep, and daily activity can influence the bigger picture, and I don’t want to ignore those factors. Here’s another example. Let’s take two women who are both 45 years old, both weigh 155 pounds, and both strength train three days a week.

 

[00:20:51] Emily Field: One has a sedentary job and averages 3,000 steps a day. The other works on her feet and averages 12,000 steps a day. If they select the same general activity category on a calculator, they might receive very different recommendations. But once I understand what their days actually look like, I’m gonna arrive at very different calorie estimates.

 

[00:21:13] Emily Field: And neither woman is doing anything wrong. Their bodies simply have different energy demands. This is also why I want women to be careful about assuming that someone else’s macros should work for them. Maybe your friend is losing weight at 1,900 calories and you don’t understand why you’re not getting the same results, but you’re not living in her body, following her daily routine, or working with her health history.

 

[00:21:36] Emily Field: Comparing your numbers to hers doesn’t tell us whether either plan is appropriate. And that brings us to the final decision where we actually put numbers to all the information that we’ve gathered. Decision number five, what starting targets make sense and how will we know whether they’re working? By the time I get to this part of a custom macro calculation, I’ve already learned quite a bit about a person.

 

[00:21:59] Emily Field: I know what she’s trying to accomplish, what she’s currently eating, how her body appears to be responding, what her health history looks like, and what her lifestyle and training demand. Now I can use that information to estimate her energy needs and decide what kind of nutrition prescription makes sense.

 

[00:22:15] Emily Field: And yes, this is where calculations come into play. There are established equations that we can use to estimate resting energy expenditure, and from there we can account for activity and other relevant factors to estimate daily total energy needs. But I want you to understand that these are still estimates.

 

[00:22:32] Emily Field: Even when I have a thorough health history and a lot of useful information, I’m not measuring your exact metabolism through this questionnaire. I’m using the best available information to make an informed professional recommendation. From there, I have to decide whether we’re targeting maintenance calories, creating a modest deficit for fat loss, or recommending an intake that better supports the client’s current needs and goals.

 

[00:22:55] Emily Field: If fat loss is appropriate, I generally prefer a moderate approach that gives someone a reasonable chance of preserving muscle, training effectively, and following the plan consistently. Because while a larger deficit might produce faster weight loss in the short term, that doesn’t automatically make it a better strategy.

 

[00:23:14] Emily Field: Then we have to determine the macro distribution. Protein is a priority for most of the women I work with because it plays an important role in supporting muscle maintenance and growth, recovery, and satiety. And this becomes especially relevant when someone is strength training or pursuing fat loss.

 

[00:23:29] Emily Field: But even protein recommendations need context. A person’s body size, goals, training, and relevant medical considerations can influence what I recommend. Once we have an appropriate protein target, we need to allocate enough dietary fat and carbohydrates to support overall nutrition, health, and training.

 

[00:23:47] Emily Field: And I don’t believe there’s one perfect ratio of protein, fat, and carbohydrates that everyone needs to follow. For some women, a higher carbohydrate approach makes a lot of sense because they’re active and they enjoy carbohydrate-rich foods and perform well with that intake. For others, a different distribution might be more comfortable or practical based on food preferences, appetite, or health considerations.

 

[00:24:10] Emily Field: We’re looking for a set of targets that makes nutritional sense and is realistic enough to follow. Because I could calculate an absolutely beautiful macro prescription on paper, but if it requires you to eat foods that you hate, rearrange your entire life, or prepare six elaborate meals a day, how useful is it really?

 

[00:24:29] Emily Field: This is something I think that gets lost in the conversation about finding your perfect macros. There is no magical combination of protein, fat, and carbohydrates that’s going to make consistency irrelevant. The best starting targets are the ones that fit your needs and give you a reasonable opportunity to follow through.

 

[00:24:47] Emily Field: Now, here’s another important piece. The first prescription is not necessarily the final prescription. Let’s say I give you a starting target of 1,850. I don’t want you thinking that 1,849 calories is perfect and 1,851 calories means you’ve failed. That number is an estimate informed by your circumstances.

 

[00:25:08] Emily Field: It isn’t the exact threshold your body recognizes. Over time, we look at what’s happening. Are your average weight and measurements changing in the direction you’d expect? How are your workouts going? Are you recovering? Are you constantly hungry? Are you able to follow the plan with reasonable consistency?

 

[00:25:27] Emily Field: If someone is losing weight at an appropriate rate, maintaining strength, and feeling pretty good, there’s probably no reason to rush into changing things. If someone isn’t seeing the expected trend, I want to explore adherence, tracking accuracy, activity, and the amount of time we’ve been evaluating before deciding whether the calorie target needs to change.

 

[00:25:47] Emily Field: And if someone is experiencing excessive hunger, fatigue, or declining performance, those are important signs that the plan deserves a much closer look. I think this is one of the biggest mindset shifts I want women to make around macros. Your targets aren’t a test you pass or fail every day. They’re a tool we use to support a goal, and we evaluate whether that tool is doing its job Let’s pull all of this together with one final example.

 

[00:26:14] Emily Field: Imagine three women who enter their information into the same online macro calculator and receive roughly the same estimated maintenance calories. The first woman has been eating consistently, strength training regularly, sleeping well, and maintaining her weight. She’s interested in losing a modest amount of body fat, and there’s no obvious reason she couldn’t pursue a moderate deficit.

 

[00:26:35] Emily Field: For her, that might be a reasonable next step. The second woman has spent the last 15 years on and off diets. She’s never intentionally eaten at maintenance. She’s struggling to recover from her workouts, and she’s approaching this new macro calculation with the assumption that she just needs to eat even less than before.

 

[00:26:53] Emily Field: With her, I might recommend a completely different direction. Maybe we spend time establishing a consistent maintenance intake, improving her nutrition habits, and supporting her training before we pursue fat loss. The third woman is managing type 2 diabetes and persistent digestive symptoms. For her, I’d want to understand her medications, glucose management, meal patterns, food intolerances, and whether there are concerns that she needs medical attention.

 

[00:27:20] Emily Field: The calorie recommendation might end up looking similar to the one of the other women, but the approach to her meal structure and food choices and overall priorities could be quite different. This is the same starting calculator estimate, three different people, potentially three different nutrition strategies, and none of those differences are captured by simply plugging in height, weight, and age into an equation.

 

[00:27:45] Emily Field: That’s the real value of stepping back and looking at the person rather than treating the calculator output like the final answer So if you’ve been wondering whether your macros are actually right for you, I hope this episode has given you a better understanding of what goes into answering that question.

 

[00:28:02] Emily Field: Before I recommend calorie and macro targets, I wanna know five things. First, what are we trying to accomplish? Are we pursuing fat loss, muscle gain, better performance, maintenance, or a combination of goals? Second, what is your current intake doing? Not just what number you’re aiming for, but how consistently you’re eating that amount and what your weight trends, hunger, energy, and performance are telling us.

 

[00:28:27] Emily Field: Third, what does your health and dieting history tell me? Have you been chronically dieting? Have you been managing a condition that affects your nutritional needs? Are stress, recovery, or digestive symptoms factors we need to account for? Fourth, what does your daily life demand? How active are you outside the gym?

 

[00:28:46] Emily Field: What kind of training are you doing? What other factors influence your energy needs? And finally, how do we turn that information into a useful starting prescription, and what will we monitor to determine whether it’s working? I want you to notice that only one of those five decisions is really about calculating numbers.

 

[00:29:06] Emily Field: The rest are about understanding the person, and I think that’s an important distinction because there are so many women out there who are incredibly committed to their health. They’re lifting weights, prioritizing protein, going on walks, and making an effort to eat well, but they’re still following a calorie target that they chose years ago without really understanding where it came from.

 

[00:29:26] Emily Field: Maybe that number is appropriate for them, maybe it isn’t. But I don’t want you spending another year assuming the answer is always to eat less when you haven’t taken the time to understand how much food your body actually needs. Instead of asking, “What’s the lowest number of calories I can eat and still lose weight?”

 

[00:29:43] Emily Field: I want you asking, “What’s an appropriate amount of food for my body, my goals, my health history, and the lifestyle I’m trying to build?” Those are two very different questions, and I think the second one is much more likely to lead you toward the results you can actually maintain. If you’re ready to stop guessing at your calorie and macro targets, remember that my custom macro calculations are part of this year’s Black Friday promotion.

 

[00:30:07] Emily Field: You’ll find the details and a link to get started in the show notes. Thank you so much for spending this time with me today, and if this episode helped you think differently about your calorie needs, I would love for you to share it with a friend who might be questioning her own numbers

follow Macros Made Easy on Instagram for more macro tracking how-tos